Private Internet Access vs Mullvad: Which Should You Buy?

Affiliate disclosure: some links below are affiliate links. If you buy through them we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. See our full disclosure.

If you’ve spent any time in the self-hosting community, you know that your network perimeter is everything. Whether you’re tunneling back into your home lab or just trying to mask your footprint while browsing, a VPN isn’t a luxury—it’s a baseline requirement for sanity.

The problem is that the VPN market is bloated with “lifestyle” brands. As someone who cares more about packets and privacy than flashy marketing, I tend to narrow my field down to tools that actually do one thing well. Today, we are looking at two heavyweights from opposite ends of the philosophy spectrum: Private Internet Access and Mullvad.

One is built for the budget-conscious power user who wants maximum device coverage; the other is a fortress designed for those who view anonymity as a non-negotiable right. Let’s break down which one belongs on your machine.

Quick verdict

If you are…Buy this…
On a strict budget and need to cover every device in the housePrivate Internet Access
A privacy purist who wants zero logs and total anonymityMullvad

Spec-by-spec

FeaturePrivate Internet AccessMullvad
CategoryVPNVPN
TypeSaaSSaaS
Pricing$2/mo€5/mo
Best ForBudget configurable VPNPrivacy-max flat-rate VPN
JurisdictionUSNot specified
Log PolicyNot specifiedNo logs
Affiliate ProgramYesNO affiliate program

The Analysis: Two Different Philosophies

The “Set and Forget” Budget Approach

When I look at Private Internet Access, I see a tool designed for the mass market that doesn’t sacrifice configurability. At $2/mo, it is aggressively priced. For the homelabber who has a dozen different VMs, containers, and old laptops floating around the house, the ability to cover “many devices” without breaking the bank is a massive win.

However, there is a trade-off here that you cannot ignore: jurisdiction. PIA operates under US jurisdiction. In my world, where we prioritize sovereignty over our data, this is a significant point of consideration. If your threat model involves avoiding agencies within the Five Eyes alliance, this might be a dealbreaker for you. But if you just need a cheap, configurable tunnel to keep your traffic tidy and your budget intact, it’s hard to argue with the price point.

The Anonymity Fortress

Then we have Mullvad. Mullvad doesn’t play the typical SaaS game. They don’t do “introductory offers” or complex pricing tiers; they stick to a flat €5/mo. In an industry where most companies try to lock you into two-year contracts, this transparency is refreshing.

The real draw here is the anonymity. Mullvad focuses on being “anonymous,” and their “no logs” policy provides the peace of mind that those of us in the privacy community crave. Interestingly, they have NO affiliate program. While that might seem like a missing feature to some, to me, it’s a signal of intent. They aren’t paying people to shill for them; they are letting the product and its privacy credentials speak for themselves.

Pros & Cons

Private Internet Access

Pros:

  • Unbeatable Price: At $2/mo, it is an incredibly accessible entry point.
  • Device Density: Excellent for those who need to connect many devices simultaneously.
  • Configurability: Great for users who want a budget-friendly but flexible setup.

Cons:

  • Jurisdiction: Being based in the US is a major downside for high-security privacy seekers.

Mullvad

Pros:

  • True Anonymity: Built from the ground up to keep the user anonymous.
  • Strict Logging Policy: A clear “no logs” stance.
  • Predictable Pricing: The flat €5/mo rate means no surprises or predatory renewals.

Cons:

  • Higher Cost: More expensive than PIA on a monthly basis.
  • No Incentives: Because they have NO affiliate program, you won’t find the typical “refer-a-friend” discounts here.

Which should you buy?

Choosing between these two comes down to your personal threat model and your wallet.

Choose Private Internet Access if you are managing a household full of devices and need a VPN that “just works” without eating into your hardware budget. It is the pragmatic choice for those who prioritize cost-efficiency and device count over geopolitical jurisdiction concerns.

Choose Mullvad if you view your digital footprint as something to be erased entirely. If you are okay with paying a premium (€5/mo) to ensure that no logs are kept and your identity remains anonymous, this is the gold standard. It’s for the user who wants a VPN that behaves more like a utility and less like a marketing machine.

FAQ

Is Mullvad more expensive than Private Internet Access? Yes. Mullvad costs €5/mo, whereas Private Internet Access is priced at $2/mo.

Does Mullvad have a referral or affiliate program? No, Mullvad explicitly has NO affiliate program.

Which VPN is better for users with many devices? Private Internet Access is listed as being best for those who need to cover many devices on a budget.

What is the main privacy concern with Private Internet Access? The primary concern noted is its US jurisdiction, which may be a factor depending on your specific privacy requirements.

Our top VPN pick

Whichever you choose here, our overall top pick is NordVPN — independently audited no-logs policy, one of the largest server networks, fast speeds, and Threat Protection built in. It’s the VPN we recommend for most people. **